The ratio of Chatsky to Sophia. Worthy of the love Chatsky to Sophia?

Date:

2018-03-21 19:44:17

Views:

496

Rating:

1Like 0Dislike

Share:

Table of contents:

“Woe from wit” is a work versatile. It is possible to see and social parody, and criticism of the regime, and the historical sketch of manners. Not the last place in the book is love and intrigue. The ratio of Chatsky to Sophia, their feelings – the core that is the basis of the plot, fills it with life and emotion.

Characters eyes pupils

To Analyze “Woe from wit" endlessly. Consider the individual plot feature of Sofya and ChatskyMoves with a magnifying glass, comparing quotes from the memoirs of contemporaries and biographies of prospective prototypes. But that approach professional analyst, literary critic. In school lessons the work is read differently. And analyzed in accordance with the recommendations of methodological issues.

There is a certain type that the Ministry of education regularly invites students to reflect on and subsequent writing essays: “Worthy of the love Chatsky to Sophia?”, “whether the Law was Madame Karenina, deciding to divorce?”, “Characteristics of deeds of Prince Myshkin”. Not quite clear what it wants to achieve the education system. This analysis anything to do with the actual literature does not. It is rather a monologue grandmother at the door, debating if was Claudia from the third apartment, kicked when Vaska-alcoholic, or still not right.

And life experience of the student of 9th class hardly gives an indication of how it was necessary to do the character. It is unlikely he will be able to understand that annoying Sophia Used and why. Except, of course, the obvious things – those mentioned by the heroine herself.

Recommended

LP - a woman or a man, and is it important?

LP - a woman or a man, and is it important?

Those who have ever bothered to become acquainted with the works of the magic of the singer LP, was irrevocably in love with her amazing charisma, emancipation and fascinating game now popular on the ukulele tool. Her real fans have stopped to wonder...

The Song

The Song "Gibraltar-Labrador". Meanings and images

The Song "Gibraltar-Labrador" Vyacheslav Butusov became known to the General public in 1997. She became part of the sound track of the famous film by Alexei Balabanov, "Brother 2". Today it listens to the second generation of fans of Russian rock. In...

Ewan McGregor: filmography, biography actor

Ewan McGregor: filmography, biography actor

Audiences love films with participation of actors of the ordinary. So in the eyes of many was Ewan McGregor. His filmography includes more than sixty works, with diverse and multifaceted. Evan with equal success, delves into the images of rich and po...

Features of perception plays

Traditionalattitude Chatsky to Sophia the interpretation of the play “Woe from wit” follows. - Principled, noble and uncompromising. Surrounding – low, narrow-minded and conservative, not understanding and not accepting advanced, innovative ideology is the main character. Chatsky broadcasts, convicts and nasmeshnitsy, the word reeks of the evils of society, and society is writhing with well-aimed hits, mad and angry.

It is Difficult to say whether this effect was achieved Griboyedov. There is the opposite version, explaining the design plays with the endless monologues of appeals of the protagonist because the author of the parodied image of a liberal, talking a lot and doing nothing. And characterization of Sofya and Chatsky is largely shaped by the perception of how the work of the reader. In the first case, he sees the hero of the idealist and not to assess the gusts a housewife, in the second – a windbag demagogue and… still do not appreciate it impulses a housewife. Is it so?

Details plot conflicts

Who are Chatsky and Sophia? Him – twenty-one, she – seventeen. Broke up three years worthy Sophia love ChatskyAgo. I left as soon as he reached adulthood, left home guardian and returned to the family estate. Did not come, did not write. Just up and disappeared. For what reasons – not so important. But what it must feel like love fourteen-year-old girl when the man she considers her lover, her future fiance, so she just goes and leaves? Not for a week, not a month. For three years. Even at thirty it – big time. And in fourteen-eternity. What was he doing all this time? Of whom thought? It can be sure that love is still alive?

In fourteen years, with teenage maximalism, teenage emotion. Critics present to the girl requirements that not every adult woman is consistent. And the attitude Chatsky to Sophia-not an obvious point. It is enough to imagine the situation through the eyes of the girl, and not an omniscient reader who Griboyedov all told. It is not logical to ask: does Sophia keep at least some feelings for Caccamo? And if so-why? He's not her husband, not the groom. He – romantic admirer, at one point uporovsky, like a moth from the glade, for the next three years. The impulse of the soul he had. Feelings. Offended dignity. And she? She should not have been in this situation feel hurt, confusion, anger? The frustration finally? Penelope, of course, waiting for the Odyssey much longer – but the situation was quite different. Chatsky-not Odyssey.

Sophia closeup

But it's all behind the scenes. Yes, the attentive reader will understand everything, if what does Sophia usedThink about it, but the situation still served hints, snatches of conversations, memories. Therefore, it can slip away from the man, accustomed to see only the storyline works. And what is it?

She was suddenly returned to the house of the guardian about three years. He's excited, he's excited, he's happy. The ratio of Chatsky to Sophia remained the same. But she already loves someone else. First, even children, love forgotten. She is passionate about the life around us. Alas, the choice is very bad. Objectively-he is poor, the lower class, this is an obvious mismatch. And subjectively, he is a weak - willed sycophant, flatterer and insignificance. Although I have to say, the prospect of him pretty good. Hollywood has already begun to make a career and copes with the task. We can assume that the new choice of Sophia will go far

In this case the young man does not love, he's just afraid to admit it. And the prospect of a great marriage and I am sure, very sympathetic to him. Often it is this unfortunate choice is blamed in the girl, answering the question whether Sophia love Chatsky? Traded eagle on a plucked Sparrow, silly.

Who is Sophia? The girl who grew up without a mother, locked up, almost not leaving the house. Her circle of friends – a father who has no clue about parenting in General and daughters in particular, and the maid. What could Sophia know about men? How could she take any experience? The only source of information – books. Ladies French novels, which allows her to read Papa. As such she could see the insincerity of the person who logged the confidence of a much more Mature and experienced people? It's just unrealistic.

Sophia is very young, she's naïve, romantic and inexperienced. Hollywood – the only young man, whom she sees almost every day. He is poor, honest, miserable, timid and charming. All the same, as in the novels that Sophia reads every day. Of course, she just could not fall in love.

What now?

The same careful attention should be paid and the identity of Chatsky. This error Chatsky and SophiaDoes Sophia? If you look at the situation objectively – a big loss in her life this marriage?

Jackomo twenty-one. He did not find. Tried there, tried here. But… “to serve would be happy fawn sick”. A position that would meet his demands, still can not come across. What means living life? He has an estate. And, of course, serfs. This is the main source of income of young liberal. The man who fervently and sincerely deplored serfdom, calls it barbarism and savagery. So here's a fun problem.

Do you have dark prospects? Career he will not do, obviously. Neither military – he is not stupid Martinet. Neither financial – he is not a dealer. Neither political – he would not betray the ideals. Another Demidov him not to become – the grip is not the same. All of those who say, not from those who do.

His Reputation is already ruined, society runs away from it like the plague. It is highly likely that my entire life I will stay in the family name, occasionally going to the resorts and to the capital. That annoying Sophia Used now, will only improve with age it will become even more caustic and cynical, exasperated from the constant failures and disappointments. Can a marriage with such a person be considered a good party? And whether Sophia is happy with him – just like human beings happy? Even if I really loves her and will keep that love? Unlikely. Perhaps, the denouement of the play is tragic only for the main character. Sophia just got lucky. Cheaply.

And question

Although, when the ratio of Chatsky to Sophia is discussed in the key if she is worthy of such great love or no – is in itself strange. Unethical. Is it possible to be worthy of love? Is that a prize? A promotion? The compliance office? Love not for something, just like. Because this man and no one else. That's life. And no love requires an object to experience a reciprocal feeling. Alas. The question itself is incorrect. So it is impossible. Love-not potatoes at the market to say, is it worth it, ask for it. And even the pupils should be clearly aware of it, not to mention older people.


Article in other languages:

BE: https://tostpost.com/be/mastactva-zabavy/24880-sta-lenne-chackogo-da-sof-vartaya-l-sof-ya-lyubov-chackogo.html

DE: https://tostpost.com/de/kunst-und-unterhaltung/24897-haltung-ist-alles-gut-zu-sophia-verdient-ob-sophia-die-liebe-chatsky.html

ES: https://tostpost.com/es/arte-y-entretenimiento/24922-la-relaci-n-de-chackogo-a-sof-e-es-digno-de-si-el-amor-de-sofia-chacko.html

KK: https://tostpost.com/kk/ner-zh-ne-oyyn-sauy/24862-atynasy-chackogo---sof-e-layy-li-sof-ya-mahabbat-chackogo.html

PL: https://tostpost.com/pl/sztuka-i-rozrywka/24794-stosunek-chackogo-do-zofii-warta-czy-zofia-mi-o-ci-chackogo.html

PT: https://tostpost.com/pt/artes-e-entretenimento/24798-a-atitude-timo-ao-sof-e-digno-de-se-sophia-de-amor--timo.html

TR: https://tostpost.com/tr/sanat-ve-e-lence/24867-genel-chackogo-bu-sof-e-lay-k-m-sophia-a-k-chackogo.html

UK: https://tostpost.com/uk/mistectvo-ta-rozvagi/24850-stavlennya-chac-kogo-do-sof-g-dna-sof-ya-lyubov-chac-kogo.html






Alin Trodden - author of the article, editor
"Hi, I'm Alin Trodden. I write texts, read books, and look for impressions. And I'm not bad at telling you about it. I am always happy to participate in interesting projects."

Comments (0)

This article has no comment, be the first!

Add comment

Related News

How to draw a plane beautiful?

How to draw a plane beautiful?

we All know how to make paper airplanes – this simple art has known every student of our country. But to draw it so that everyone around gasped, not everyone can. It seems that to represent this on paper no less difficult th...

Harmoniously matched actors.

Harmoniously matched actors. "Terminator: Yes come Savior"

a large-Scale military film with the battles on water, land and air, with computer and all kinds of Schwarzenegger terminator – so designated the fourth part of cult franchises participated in the filming of the actors. &ldq...

The series

The series "the Last meeting": actors and roles, the plot

"the Last meeting" – Russian series, released in 2011 in the genre of action-Thriller. What attracted the viewer another Russian blockbuster "the Last meeting"? The actors that have played here, familiar to every viewer. In ...

How to bet? How to bet on sports

How to bet? How to bet on sports

the Stakes in one form or another has existed in world since time immemorial. It could be an ordinary dispute, which interest was reinforced by material values. Especially popular have always enjoyed a bet at the racetrack, which ...

Marlon Wayans, actor.

Marlon Wayans, actor. "Without feelings" is a great "black" Comedy

Actors of the movie “unconscious” in 1998, the year I woke up famous. Nobody expected that this black Comedy, filmed Penelope of sfiris (“Police Hollywood”, “Wayne's World”) will be popular. Muc...

Announcer Kirillov Igor Leonidovich: biography, personal life

Announcer Kirillov Igor Leonidovich: biography, personal life

To millions of viewers speaker Kirillov became the personification of the Soviet era on television. It was he who announced to the whole country that Yuri was the first to go into space. It is to him that turned ordinary citizens ...