The film "girls": the opinions of viewers, critics and the Orthodox Church

Date:

2018-03-28 22:38:17

Views:

482

Rating:

1Like 0Dislike

Share:

Table of contents:

In 2016, the screens out the film “Disciple”. Reviews about it are mixed. The picture tells the story of the confrontation between religious and liberal values. It raises very important for modern society. That carries faith without love? Where is the line between fanaticism and extremism? What is the role of adults in the moral education of children? How to relate to Christian precepts? To answer these questions is not easy. But think over them – is already half the battle. Below are the responses and reviews on another sensational film by Kirill Serebrennikov “Disciple”.

the apprentice movie reviews

An absolute success

The film has received a wide resonance. Critics found its quality and relevance. The acting and even praised to the skies. The film was nominated for “nick” in the eight positions, but received the prize only for the female role of the second plan. Work from Julia Aug made the jury an exceptional experience. On «Golden eagle» the painting is not appreciated. It was considered in three categories, but did not give a single award. But at the Cannes film festival, the project received the award named after the Francois Chalet. It is awarded by an independent panel of judges for the accurate representation of reality. Chapter awards Bob Swaim noted that the problems raised in the film touch not only Russia but the whole world. To «Palme», unfortunately, has not held the film “Disciple”. Reviews of world public opinion about him quite enthusiastic.

student film 2016 testimonials

Storyline

What is so special about the film Serebrennikov “Disciple”? Comments about it are intriguing. According to spectators, it tells about a guy named Venya Ugine. He is being raised in a single-parent family, lives with his mother, who barely makes a living and has no time to follow the son. Once in the family, a conflict occurs. The guy does not want to go to the pool with classmates. Mom trying to find the cause of the strange behavior of the son. During the conflict, there are different versions, up to an uncontrollable erection. Venia shrugs off all my mom's theories, offering their religious beliefs. A parent raises his laugh. So our hero finds himself in the Bible. Her reading completely turns his life upside down.

Recommended

The Song

The Song "Gibraltar-Labrador". Meanings and images

The Song "Gibraltar-Labrador" Vyacheslav Butusov became known to the General public in 1997. She became part of the sound track of the famous film by Alexei Balabanov, "Brother 2". Today it listens to the second generation of fans of Russian rock. In...

Ewan McGregor: filmography, biography actor

Ewan McGregor: filmography, biography actor

Audiences love films with participation of actors of the ordinary. So in the eyes of many was Ewan McGregor. His filmography includes more than sixty works, with diverse and multifaceted. Evan with equal success, delves into the images of rich and po...

Guitar Colombo - tools from Chinese manufacturer

Guitar Colombo - tools from Chinese manufacturer

Once upon a time in Russia was imported guitars under the famous brand name Skylark. However, the time has come, and Chinese manufacturers began to divide among themselves the brand. It should say that under this brand in China produces a huge amount...

Student raises real religious rebellion. He denounces the girls in immodest bikini, teachers quotes lines from the Holy Scriptures, throws away from his room all the things, leaving only a mattress. His behavior, he brings mom to tears, blaming her for the divorce with my father. In General, the guy is up in arms against the world and trying to improve it according to their understanding. His behavior seriously interested only biology teacher Elena Lvovna and the priest of the local Church. But for Benjamin no authority. It is in close contact with a boy-a cripple George, which everyone does. But sees it as not a friend and a pupil and follower. It all ends tragically. Christian extremism is the main character reaches the highest point. In the end, one person dies. But the boy is not stopping. The guy believes that his love for God justifies everything. And the wicked should be punished. Therefore, he accuses the teacher with liberal views of indecent assault. Elena Lvovna trying to fire, but she refuses to leave the school, stating that it is in place.film student critics 'reviews

Crisis of faith

In the picture reveals a serious problem. It is no secret that in today's world there is a crisis of faith. It is associated with great achievements of mankind in science and technology. Many people have learned to do this myself, so I decided that I can do without God. But life without faith is fraught with great inconveniences. Not someone to rely on, no one to complain to, nothing to follow. And when an inexperienced teenager finds a Bible he makes its contents completely unexpected insights.

Reviews of the movie “Disciple” (2016) tend to confusion. How could a normal teenager to bring adults to this state? It's simple. The guy found support in very authoritative source-the Bible. Joy enjoys the fact that around it is limited and ignorant people. They go on about the arrogant student, and he makes everyone dance to its tune. One Elena L. gives it back. However, she uses his own weapon. It forces the teenager to fall even lower. He shows the true properties of his nature-deceit, cowardice and extreme cruelty.film student reviews 2016 Orthodox Church

No love

Reviews of the Orthodox Church in the film “Disciple” 2016 make you think. For example, priest Vasily Kutsenko States that the forwards took the line from Scripture too categorical. He saw in them only the threat of punishment for sinners, and insists on her throughout the picture. A teenager sees only one side of the coin: God can destroy and punish. But the essence of religious obedience, not in fear but in love. The Apostle John the Theologian says in this regard that in love there is no fear, but perfect love casts out fear. Attempts of understanding this phrase in the film are almost there. In the story, Elena L. is trying to understand love in the Evangelical sense. But also comes to the absurdconclusion.

The Orthodox Church in reviews of the film of 2016. “Student” absolutely adequately assess the situation. She realizes that the film is trying to convey to the audience the obvious fact that the Bible cannot be interpreted literally. It's full of allegories and metaphors that correctly unprepared people can not understand. And the speech in the film is not about religion, but about how to manipulate people's minds. Sometimes it uses the Word of God. But all this is irrelevant to the true faith.

Rave reviews

The film by Kirill Serebrennikov “Disciple” the reviews are mainly positive. The Director of the film called the best in cinema. The script is described as deep, alive and relevant. Actors don't get tired of praising for credibility. Many believe that this pattern of extremism that originates at the household level. In the tape faced by two incompatible world – enlightenment and ignorance. As they say, the sleep of reason produces monsters. Ignorance – the main enemy of common sense. In the picture it prevails and, in the end, almost wins out. But on the bright side doesn't give up. Teacher Elena L. did not leave the school. She washes their shoes nailed to the floor and says to colleagues: “I am here in his place, and you don't!”. According to the reviews of the movie “Disciple” (2016), a large part of the audience his story creates hope for a better future.the apprentice movie reviews the Orthodox Church

The latest news

The reviews highlight the relevance of the tape. Talk about it, how about the anti-terrorism Manifesto. After all, the main character of force trying to impose to others the spiritual ties that need to replace humanity, love and compassion. But what drives Venu Winam? Clearly not the love of God. He seeks to assert itself, considering that it is all good. The guy chooses from the Bible only those phrases that are advantageous to him. He quotes them by heart. He manages to force himself to hear. But before him no one noticed! And then the blame indulges in all serious. Forget the morality of the ten commandments that are the Foundation of the Scriptures. It is meanness, forgery, perjury, and, eventually, murder. And all this because others do not stopped all the psychosis in the beginning. The guy turned into a terrorist. He creates his own little revolution in a particular school.

the apprentice movie reviews the Church

Negative feedback

However, not all of the audience called positive emotions the film “Disciple”. Reviews about him as antireligious and misanthropic propaganda of yellow journalism filled the Internet. So the audience did not like the pronounced bigotry of the main character. Many have decided that they showed a teenager with severe mental disorder. They say, affected by the lack of male parenting and lack of attention from the mother. The boy felt useless, and this lack of demand resulted in controlled no nonsense. There were people that was hard to watch this film. Religious background acted on their nerves, and Nude revolted to depth of soul. Some were upset crumpled finale in the movie “Disciple”. Reviews indicate that it spoiled the good impression which had been left spectators from artists and non-trivial story.

Cartoon reality

One of the reviewers calls the picture Serebrennikov strong, but comical and viscous work. He says it – to denounce an indefinite attitude to religion, which dominates in modern society. The critic also claims that the story is very relevant and immediately acquires the most acute recent problems. This and the desire of the Orthodox Church to participate in the public processes of the country, and radicalism, which overcomes some of the members of the religious community, and the desperate ignorance of the overwhelming mass of people, and domestic anti-Semitism and lack of common sense. Among the actors, mainly, we distinguish two – starring Peter Skvortsov and Victoria Isakov.

film student Kirill Serebrennikov reviews

Laughter through tears

Critical acclaim for the film “Student” in General positive. Some note the deliberate slowness of the action in the picture. In addition, there is a certain dissonance. The fact that the tape is filled with comic details. But because of the dreary, cutting the ear of the soundtrack, funny it seems pathetic and even scary. In fact, it is impossible not to laugh at the scene where the main character tries the power of thought to grow the crippled leg. Another interesting point can be called when the character of Alexander Gorchilin trying to thank you for the daily bread of the Lord, but always switched to mother Veni Ugine – true earn in the family.

Beam of light

Incredibly comical scenes happened with the participation of Viktoria Isakova. It is a real diamond adorning his sparkling talent, a picture of Kirill Serebrennikov. According to the critics, the film “Disciple” (2016) never have taken place without the participation of this wonderful actress. Her heroine is trying to resist the wanton teenager. In her final monologue is the main idea of the tape. However, the character of the biology teacher Elena Lvovna also deliberately caricatured.Girl meets blunt, a PE teacher and has been practicing the original teaching methods. It is to criticize, and enterprising Benjamin uses it.

Dialog with the priest

Reviews of the Church in the film “Student” is very discreet. Priests say that the film shows a teenager in a state of acute mental disorder. You can't throw phrases from the Bible taken out of context. This makes them meaningless and even dangerous. The priest in the movie "Disciple" - a common administrator. Talking to the ignorant mother Veni eyes, he knows how to impress. But the controversy raged with young talent, he has no chance. The guy in the nines carries the philosophy of the hapless preacher. This suggests that the priest can not be a formalist. Otherwise he will quickly lose all its credibility.

In conclusion

So, has become a real phenomenon in the cultural life of the country the film "Student". Reviews of Orthodox people about him were satisfactory. The religious feelings of believers were not hurt. Everyone understands that without a mentor to understand correctly the line from Scripture is not easy. The scary thing is that the aggressive part of the population may use metaphors and allegories of the Bible for personal purposes. And this can lead to disastrous consequences. Religious extremism is gaining momentum all over the world. "Student" proposes to reflect on how and why this happens.


Article in other languages:

BE: https://tostpost.com/be/mastactva-zabavy/15975-f-l-m-vuchan-vodguk-gledacho-krytyka-pravasla-nay-carkvy.html

DE: https://tostpost.com/de/kunst-und-unterhaltung/15981-der-film-der-sch-ler-die-rezensionen-der-zuschauer-kritiker-und-der-or.html

ES: https://tostpost.com/es/arte-y-entretenimiento/15993-la-pel-cula-el-disc-pulo-los-clientes-de-espectadores-y-cr-ticos-de-la.html

KK: https://tostpost.com/kk/ner-zh-ne-oyyn-sauy/15974-fil-m-o-ushy-p-k-rler-k-rermenderd-de-synshylardy-zh-ne-pravoslav-sh-r.html

PL: https://tostpost.com/pl/sztuka-i-rozrywka/15947-film-ucze-opinie-widz-w-krytyk-w-i-ko-cio-a-prawos-awnego.html

PT: https://tostpost.com/pt/artes-e-entretenimento/15948-o-filme-o-aprendiz-coment-rios-de-espectadores-cr-ticos-e-da-igreja-or.html

TR: https://tostpost.com/tr/sanat-ve-e-lence/15980-film-renci-yorumlar-izleyiciler-ele-tirmenler-ve-ortodoks-kilisesi.html

UK: https://tostpost.com/uk/mistectvo-ta-rozvagi/15966-f-l-m-uchen-v-dguki-glyadach-v-kritik-v-pravoslavno-cerkvi.html






Alin Trodden - author of the article, editor
"Hi, I'm Alin Trodden. I write texts, read books, and look for impressions. And I'm not bad at telling you about it. I am always happy to participate in interesting projects."

Comments (0)

This article has no comment, be the first!

Add comment

Related News

LP - a woman or a man, and is it important?

LP - a woman or a man, and is it important?

Those who have ever bothered to become acquainted with the works of the magic of the singer LP, was irrevocably in love with her amazing charisma, emancipation and fascinating game now popular on the ukulele tool. Her real fans ha...

Creativity and the biography of Patricia Kaas

Creativity and the biography of Patricia Kaas

Patricia Kaas – famous French singer, who became a star of a chanson of the 90-ies. Her fame was deafening, and personal life is filled with events and stories.Patricia Kaas: familythe Famous singer was born 5 December 1966....

How to draw a pencil portrait? Useful tips

How to draw a pencil portrait? Useful tips

the Ability to draw often helps in many situations. For example, you can Express your idea in drawing. Artistic skills allow you to work creatively. Also this activity helps to cope with stress, forget about problems. Moreover, it...

Who wrote

Who wrote "50 shades of grey"? Biography of the author of the novel "50 shades of grey"

the Book “50 shades of grey” became a sensation immediately after it was published. Some found it offensive and vulgar. Others have read the piece several times, hoping to be in place for someone of the main characters...

"Grandfather 005": actors and movie features

Today we talk about the movie “Ded 005”. Actors and roles are presented next. The Director made Mher Mkrtchyan and Arkadiy Grigoryan. Cinematography Arto Khachaturian, Alexei Fedorov, Vahan Ter-Akopian.abstractFirst, l...

Aspiring guitarists: the acoustic guitar differs from the classical

Aspiring guitarists: the acoustic guitar differs from the classical

For beginners it is very important to choose the instrument they will play. And here many question arises of what an acoustic guitar differs from the classical. At first glance, they are absolutely identical. But it's not. And it ...